|
Published: November 09, 2008 01:45 am
FALLS SCHOOLS SERIES: Audit deja vu
By Caitlin Murray E-mail Caitlin
Niagara Gazette
When the Niagara Falls City School District was slammed by state Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli’s Office four weeks ago for “failing to protect the taxpayers” and allowing 33 areas of misfeasance, school board members told the Niagara Gazette they didn’t know the district’s finances had gotten so out of hand.
But it wasn’t their first warning that problems existed.
In 2004, the state Education Department’s Office of Audit Services investigated the school district and found, in some cases, the exact same problems DiNapoli’s office highlighted four and a half years later.
While much less harsh on the district than DiNapoli and, at times, complimentary, the state Education Department’s audit specifically pinpointed the district’s credit card policies and purchasing procedures as being deficient. The department’s auditors found some purchases were not authorized by district administrators, lacked proper documentation and violated the district’s own policy of a $150 per diem maximum allowance.
“District administrators made charges that are not related to conference, mileage or other reimbursable expenses in performance of day-to-day duties,” the department’s audit said, including “gifts for employees” and “membership fees for various organizations.” Credit card purchases for meals and conferences also did not indicate who attended, the topics discussed or “whether a valid local government purpose” was served.
The state Education Department’s audit, which covered July 1, 2001, through Sept. 30, 2003, recommended the district develop procedures to ensure proper documentation for all purchases and ensure expenditures are approved by a purchasing agent.
But by the time DiNapoli’s office audited the district, covering a period from July 1, 2005, through Dec. 5, 2007, such recommendations apparently hadn’t been implemented.
Thousands of dollars in undocumented purchases were made using credit cards, including many by Superintendent Carmen Granto, and hundreds of purchases were made without the oversight of a purchasing agent.
“We found 106 purchases totaling $61,601 which were not supported with sufficient original documentation,” the comptroller’s office said in their report released last month. “In addition, for 108 charges totaling $59,327, we found no evidence indicating that the goods or services were actually received.”
DiNapoli’s office called for Operations and Maintenance Supervisor Lawrence “Butch” Beyer to face “disciplinary action” for circumventing the district purchasing agent by using his district credit card to buy thousands of dollars worth of equipment and making more than $100,000 worth of purchase orders without seeking competitive bids.
The comptroller’s office also called for Granto to face “appropriate action regarding the superintendent’s use of the district credit card for personal business.”
Granto charged at least $2,200 in travel expenses related to his personal consulting work, dozens of other charges for meals and car rentals without proper documentation to verify the expenditures were district-related. Granto told the Gazette he has since reimbursed those charges to the district.
While the comptroller’s audit was part of a statewide effort to review all 834 school districts by 2010, spokespeople for the state Education Department said their audit “speaks for itself,” and was likely initiated because Niagara Falls had an operating deficit for three consecutive years while spending 12 percent more per student than the state average.
When contacted about the 2004 audit, many board members said they didn’t remember it specifically and would have to see it to comment further.
Kevin Dobbs, who served as board president in 2004 and was sent a copy of the audit, according to documents, said he didn’t recall specifics from the audit, but was surprised to hear it cited similar problems as those in the comptroller’s audit. Dobbs said the board had likely relied on the district’s own auditors to indicate if there were any serious problems contained in the report.
Board member Christopher Brown said he did remember being audited and said he believed the board directed district administrators to address the problems. The district’s response dated April 23, 2004, and signed by then-Business Administrator James Ingrasci simply stated the district received the audit, did not disagree with it and would submit a corrective action plan.
Granto said all 40 recommendations in the department’s audit were addressed and provided a copy of the district’s corrective action plan from 2004.
An entry dated for July 1, 2004, states the district began reviewing and scrutinizing claims for travel, meals and other credit card charges “more closely.”
“Itemized claims with all necessary details are being required and employees are held to maximum per diem allowances,” the plan said. “Requests for conference and travel are being approved (including spending limits) by the employee’s supervisor, the treasurer, the business administrator and an assistant superintendent.”
Granto said as changes were being implemented, the comptroller’s office began reviewing the district for its own audit, finding issues that were still being corrected from the Education Department’s investigation.
“What happened was, quite frankly, we were getting dinged for the same things twice,” Granto said. “... As we were trying to correct this, they were looking at the same things two years later. A lot of this stuff we did address and a lot of it we didn’t get to yet — and a lot of it is ongoing.”
Current board president Robert Kazeangin echoed Granto’s comments, citing a close time frame between the audits in not completing all corrective actions. But with some similar issues appearing in both audits, Kazeangin said he is confident the board will address everything fully in the coming weeks.
“We really are on the right track and we’ll make sure we’ll be reviewing everything again,” he said. “We’re serious about this.”
Contact reporter Caitlin Murray
at 282-2311, ext. 2251.
|
|
|
|
 |
BILINGUAL PHONE INTERVIEWER
Bilingual Telephone interviewer. Surveys for insurance policy review. Spanish/English a Must. ft/pt & Sat. No sales/coll...>MORE
Health Care
Health Care. ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES/LAUNDRY SUPERVISORS. Excellent full-time day and evening opportunities. Experienced,...>MORE
Driver
DRIVERS – CDL A TEAM DRIVERS NEEDED FOR DEDICATED RUNS No touch freight............Good miles ...>MORE
PHONE SALES
PHONE sales, great pay, exp. a plus, nice NT office, FT/PT, hrly. +, Pete or Mike, 694-1251...>MORE
Maintenance Technician
MAINTENANCE Technician, FT, exp. needed in electrical, plumbing, heating & cooling, Apply in person bet. 9 & 5 at 6751 ...>MORE
Information Technology
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY - Niagara County Community College is seeking a Director of User and Administrative Technology Se...>MORE
Senior Citizen Program Coordinator
SENIOR CITIZEN PROGRAM COORDINATOR City of Niagara Falls Full-time position involves coord., developing & revi...>MORE
Cook
COOK full time. Apply in person only, Augie’s Diner, 2470 Military Rd. ...>MORE
RN
JOB FAIR!! Thurs., Nov 19, 2009, 11:00-5:00 RECRUITING FOR FT Physical Therapist RN’s LPN’s ...>MORE
DRIVER
Driver, light pick up & delivery, need own car, no WNY, valid NYS driver lic., good pay 694-1251...>MORE
See all ads |
VW 2001 Beetle
VW 2001 Beetle, loaded, GLX turbo, exc. cond, all service records, fun to drive, blue bk $5600, take best offer, 990-06...>MORE
1996 Ford Escort
FORD 1996 Escort 4 cyl, 2 dr, exc cond in & out, no rust, 1 owner, only 61k orig mi, $2195. 523-7102...>MORE
Chevy 1994 High Topper Van
CHEVY 1994 High topper van, high road miles, mechanically sound, $900 or bo, 716-510-8105...>MORE
Buick 2005 LeSabre
BUICK 2005 Lesabre Custom, excellent condition, fully loaded, $6700 or best offer, 754-4540...>MORE
Ford 2001 Taurus
Ford 2001 Taurus Station wagon, well maintained, 112,000 miles Siver ext. 4 dr, auto, asking $2800/BO. 716-772-2454....>MORE
Monte Carlo Z24 1998
MONTE CARLO Z24, 1998, runs good, average miles, excellent shape, $1800 , 990-2303...>MORE
Nissan 1993 4x4
NISSAN 1993 4x4, extended cab, bedliner cap, $1200 or best offer, 715-2450...>MORE
Chevy 1995 Pickup
CHEVY 1995 Pickup truck, 4WD, 5 speed, must see, never had plow on it, $2800 bo, 804-5579...>MORE
1984 Cadillac Eldorado
CADILLAC Eldorado 1984, runs, inspected, $500. 283-3552....>MORE
1999 Dodge Caravan
DODGE 1999 Caravan, 33, V6, auto, A/C, 99k miles, good cond., runs great. $1950. 525-7796...>MORE
See all ads |
|
 |
|