subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Tue, Feb 09 2010 

Published: April 22, 2008 11:21 pm    print this story  

RESTAINO: Awaiting final judgment

State Court of Appeals hears final plea to keep City Court judge on bench

By Rick Pfeiffer
E-mail Rick

Niagara Gazette

ALBANY — In the end, all Niagara Falls City Court Judge Robert Restaino’s attorney could do was ask New York’s highest court to give his client one more chance.

“Don’t impose the judicial death penalty here,” Terrence Connors said. “(Restaino) has so much more to give.”

Now six of the seven justices of the New York State Court of Appeals will consider whether to reverse a decision by the State Commission on Judicial Conduct calling for Restaino’s removal from the bench for what nine of the 10 commissioners called “an egregious and unprecedented abuse of judicial power.” Justice Eugene Pigott, who is from Erie County and is acquainted with Restaino, did not participate in the hearing Tuesday at the state capitol and will not be involved in the court’s deliberations and final decision.

The removal order for Restaino, issued Nov. 13 by the commission, stems from a March 11, 2005, incident in which Restaino briefly jailed 46 defendants from Domestic Violence Court because no one would take responsibility for an apparent ringing cell phone in his courtroom.

Restaino and his brother, Niagara County Social Services Commissioner Anthony Restaino, watched the hearing from the rear of the ornate courtroom. In a touch of irony, just before the justices entered the courtroom and the hearing began, a court clerk reminded everyone to make sure all electronic devices, “including cell phones” were turned off.

Connors told the justices what happened in Restaino’s courtroom on the day of the incident “is not contested.”

“Why it happened holds the key to whether Robert Restaino should be returned to the bench as a Niagara Falls City Court judge,” Connors told the court. “It was a perfect psychological storm and one we should have seen coming.”

Almost immediately, Judith Kaye, the court’s chief justice, interrupted.

“What were these signs (of impending trouble) that were missed?” she asked.

“(Restaino’s) incredible caseload, his unbelievable caseload,” Connors answered.

Restaino’s lawyer had already argued in a 60-plus page brief filed with the court before the hearing that Restaino’s “eruption (on the bench) was the result of severe psychological stressors at work and at home.”

“We have a lot of workaholic judges,” Justice Robert Smith said. “Are they all at risk (of behavior like Restaino’s)?”

Connors told him studies of the legal profession show many are.

“(Restaino) went completely off the rails,” Smith said. “How can we say to the community, ‘We understand what (the judge) did, but he won’t do it again?’ ”

Justice Carmen Ciparick asked if Restaino’s stress justified the action he took in jailing people to find a ringing cell phone.

“It doesn’t,” Connors responded, “but (the stress) does explain (Restaino’s actions).”

The justices wondered what effect returning Restaino to the bench would have in other cases where judges behave inappropriately and then say there was a rational explanation for that behavior. In particular, the justices questioned Connors about a 2005 case where they upheld the removal of a State Supreme Court judge in Queens who had a drug court defendant removed from her courtroom, out a back door, to keep him from being arrested by police on an unrelated crime.

“In that case, there was no evidence of mitigating factors (such as severe stress) or crisis state of mind,” Connors said. “(Judge) Restaino was remorseful (over his actions). (Justice Laura) Blackburne was not.”

Several of the justices repeatedly pressed Connors over “where to draw the line” on what behavior can be forgiven and what can not.

“Is there some conduct,” Kaye asked, “that is so intolerable (that a judge must be removed from the bench)?”

“Yes,” Connors replied.

“But with this (extreme stress) explanation, then what (conduct) would be (too extreme)?” Kaye pressed.

“There have been judges that threatened people,” Connors replied.

Kaye cut him off. “(Restaino’s conduct) is worse.”

Justice Victoria Graffeo questioned Restaino’s motivation for reversing course and releasing the 46 individuals who were jailed several hours later.

“Didn’t he do this when a reporter called?” Graffeo asked.

Connors insisted that Restaino was already making plans to release the individuals before reporters began asking questions of court officials about what had happened.

Attorney Edward Lindner, arguing on behalf of the Judicial Conduct Commission, also faced tough questions from the justices.

Kaye asked him about the large number of “friend of the court briefs,” 26 in all, that had been filed in support of Restaino.

“We have an unusual reaction here,” Kaye said. “This outpouring of support, what weight do we give this?”

Lindner dismissed the filings as having little legal merit, referring to them as nothing more than “unsworn character references.”

“This is conduct so egregious that it cannot be allowed,” Lindner told the court.

When asked by Graffeo to “define what is so egregious,” Lindner said Restaino’s actions were worse than the judge in Queens.

“Granted that (Restaino’s) behavior was weird and hard to defend,” Smith said, “is there anything (inappropriate) in (Restaino’s) life that did not occur other than on March 11, (2005)?”

Lindner said the cell phone incident was the only mark on Restaino’s record.

“So you’re saying that (Restaino’s) conduct is so egregious that it doesn’t matter what the community wants?” asked Justice Susan Read.

Lindner said the case had potential repercussions far beyond Niagara Falls.

When Kaye asked Lindner where the court should draw the line on judicial behavior, he told her Restaino’s own admissions to the commission made that easy.

“This judge knew that what he was doing was wrong at the time he was doing it,” Lindner said.

Before he sat down, Kaye asked Lindner one final question.

“Did they ever find the cell phone?” the chief justice asked.

“No,” Lindner replied.

In a final rebuttal, Connors tried to give the court one last idea for how to draw a line on judicial behavior.

“When there is some explanation and some mitigation and there is remorse and contrition,” Connor told the court.

Read still didn’t seem sure that was enough.

“(Restaino’s) caseload isn’t going to get any less,” the justice said. “How do we know this won’t happen again?”

“This man has a tremendous appreciation (of what happened),” Connors replied, “He has done what he should have done before. He has sought counseling and he knows he can’t bury himself in work.”

A decision from the court is expected by late May or early June.

print this story  



autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Premier Guide

Find a job! Find a Home! Find a car!

Featured Jobs

Cleaners Substitute
Cleaner Substitutes wanted. Previous cleaning experience preferred. Reply by Feb. 16th, to Mr. Joseph Giarrizzo, 100 Hi...>MORE

Compactor Repair Technician
COMPACTOR Repair Technician: Mechanically inclined with welding knowledge, some hydraulic and electrical understanding. ...>MORE

Youth Job Training
Niagara County YOUTH ages 18-21. Out of School? Looking for Work?
We may have the program for YOU! Call Liz for fur
...>MORE

Human Services
HUMAN SERVICES. Transitional Specialist: (PT) Niagara Falls. Assist youth with 90 day transition programming, intake and...>MORE

Counselor
COUNSELOR, PART-TIME: NIAGARA COUNTY COMMUNITY COLLEGE is seeking a part-time counselor in student services to work in t...>MORE

Home Care Aide
HomeCare Aide Certified Only. 3 overnights, transportation needed, $9.50-$11.50/hr. 298-4342 ...>MORE

RN Supervisor
RN SUPERVISORS/LPN Charge Nurse/CNA’s
Full and Part Time
Positions available.
Apply in person
Fa
...>MORE

Administrative Assistant
ADMINISTRATIVE ASSISTANT for human services agency. Resume to: ILNC, 746 Portage Rd., Niagara Falls, NY 14301. EOE...>MORE

Medical Associate
MEDICAL ASSOCIATE
Busy local Niagara Falls practice, strong computer skills, billing background helpful, $13-$14/ho
...>MORE

School Bus Drivers
SCHOOL BUS DRIVERS
We will train you to be a School Bus Driver. Classes starting now. Must have a clean drivers lic
...>MORE

See all ads

Feature Autos

Ford 1997 TAURUS
FORD 1997 taurus, runs exc. fully loaded, must see $1400 or best offer. 205-7711...>MORE

1993 Chevy Silverado
CHEVY Silverado 4x4 1993 new alt, starter, exhaust, rebuilt trans., etc. Reliable. Call 282-0465....>MORE

Pontiac 2000 Grand Prix XL
PONTIAC 2000 Grand Prix XL, black,
good condition
531-2669
...>MORE

Chrysler 2000 Concord LXI
Chrysler 2000 Concord LXI, 4 door, one owner, exc. condition, power windows, power steering, power locks, $5000 or best ...>MORE

Dodge 2001 Neon
DODGE 2001Neon, 4 dr, 4 cyl, auto, 58k mi. am/fm CD player, n o rust, like new, $3950. 525-7796...>MORE

1999 Chevy Malibu
CHEVY 1999 Malibu, needs fuel pump, $700. 282-6141 or 990-6026....>MORE

1986 Ford Mustang
FORD 1986 Mustang convertible, 5.0 body kit, 3.8L V6, 40k on new motor, runs but needs work. $700 or BO. 417-1611...>MORE

1998 Dodge Dakota Sport
DODGE 1998 Dakota Sport 3.9 V6, regular cab, exc in & out, no rust, real sharp, $2750. 523-7102...>MORE

1991 Lincoln Executive Town Car
LINCOLN 1991 Executive Town Car, 42k miles, no rust, runs, needs work, $600. 990-8895....>MORE

Ford 1999 Escort ZX2
FORD 1999 ESCORT, ZX2 Coupe, runs great, NYS inspected, exc. cond. $1650. 694-0441...>MORE

See all ads



 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index